Haha, I was there too. So far I have no regrets with the BOSS ATs. They have performed great in every scenario so far I have put them in. Haven’t had them in mud or snow yet though. Been in sand, rock, dirt, pavement, wet pavement and the have gripped!! I have no doubt they’ll do great in the other two with tread void size and being triple peak rated. On road, they are quiet and responsive. I think the silica compound has also made them durable like they claim. No visible wear yet. I am very happy with these tires. So far these are my favorite yet. I really feel they are the best of both worlds.