Thanks
@BLACKJKU but I had actually tried that previously.
HOWEVER.......
The issue has been fixed.
Here's what happened:
In the original post, I mentioned that I first replaced the starter, and after that didn't work I replaced the ignition switch.
I was getting plenty of juice to the ignition wire and power wire on the starter.
After hours of cleaning every ground, testing every wire, and coming up with nothing I decided to at least take out the new starter and return it (to get back my $200).
I re-installed the old starter and for kicks, I tried to start the Jeep.
IT STARTED. IMMEDIATELY.
I then started, turned off, started, turned off on repeat until I felt it was actually fixed.
Turns out, when I was jumping the starter with the screwdriver I had burnt up the solenoid. Ooooooops.
So, if I had not burnt up the solenoid on the new starter it would've been a $30 fix and 10 minutes.
I feel like an idiot but I am very very glad it wasn't something much worse. I think I'll keep the new TIPM because my horn and radio controls now work when they didn't before.
Thanks for everyone's help and I hope my mistake may help someone in the future.
